The Insider: News on Improving insurance in Texas TCAIS, Texas Coalition for Affordable Insurance Solutions

March 21, 2003

Proposed Legislation Won’t Help Consumers

TCAIS warns that CSSB 14 could prompt an availability crisis

Tell your legislators that CSSB 14 would take our state in the wrong direction.

ACT NOW!


See how the number of companies doing business in Texas has decreased substantially over the past decade. (PDF)

Chart 1 | Chart 2

Austin - The Texas Coalition for Affordable Insurance Solutions (TCAIS) warns that the committee substitute to Senate Bill 14 will hurt Texas homeowners and drivers by creating an even more unpredictable insurance market. TCAIS believes the legislation approved by the Senate Business and Commerce Committee yesterday does not address the underlying problems in the Texas insurance market. CSSB 14 now moves to the full Senate for a vote.

"At this critical juncture in the insurance debate, legislators need to focus on solutions that will draw more insurance companies to the Texas market, ultimately generating more competitive rates and more choices for consumers. This bill does not address the core problem in the Texas homeowners insurance market, a lack of companies willing to do business in the state," said TCAIS Director Beaman Floyd. "More onerous regulations mean the current unpredictable conditions will only get worse. This legislation will not help consumers, rather, it will create even more trouble on the insurance horizon by further threatening the availability and affordability of insurance in Texas."

TCAIS believes that meaningful insurance reform should give Texans more choices over the types of insurance policies they can purchase at more competitive prices. The current proposal threatens the stability of the Texas market and for consumers the end result could mean fewer choices among companies doing business in Texas.

"If Texans want more choices in coverage and more affordable prices, then the solution is to improve the market by giving insurance companies the freedom to compete," Floyd said.

"Don’t just get mad, get it right" is the message TCAIS has been delivering to legislators. Texans deserve the full benefits of a healthy competitive market with consumer protections designed to make sure companies are financially healthy and treat their policy holders fairly.


In the News

New Jersey Senate approves insurance reform plan

"Industry officials have complained that strict regulations in the state make it hard to turn a profit and companies that are losing money are unable to get out of the market."

The Associated Press
March 20, 2003, Thursday

Trenton, NJ - The Senate on Thursday approved an auto insurance reform plan that Gov. James E. McGreevey says will eventually lower rates.

The plan is intended to boost competition among companies. State regulators argue that if more agencies compete for business, rates will eventually fall.

After months of delay while lawmakers awaited McGreevey's proposal, the Senate bill moved quickly through the Legislature in the past week. It still must be approved by the Assembly.

Insurers were pleased the Senate acted quickly on the bill.

“The swift passage shows the consensus on the issue and bipartisan support," said John Tiene of the Insurance Council of New Jersey.

Industry officials have complained that strict regulations in the state make it hard to turn a profit and companies that are losing money are unable to get out of the market.

Under current law, the process for an unprofitable insurer to withdraw from the state's insurance market can take seven to ten years.

In addition to easing some regulations, the reform plan will raise rates for drivers with more the four motor vehicle points. The bill also will expedite the rate approval process and phase-out the "take all comers" law that requires insurers to write policies for all drivers.

Quick action on the bill is needed so New Jersey policy holders can find auto insurance coverage required by law, said Banking and Insurance Commissioner Holly Bakke.

"I want to thank the senators for realizing that the availability problem in the marketplace warranted immediate attention," Bakke said.


About TCAIS: TCAIS member companies include: Allstate Insurance Company, American Insurance Association, Nationwide Insurance, State Farm Insurance Companies and USAA.
Click here for more information on TCAIS solutions: seven guidelines for insurance reform in Texas.